Chromecast and How Google Cracked the Code of Video

Posted on: July 25, 2013
Posted in Mobile, Strategy

chromecast

When Google launched Chromecast I assumed it was based on the open source version of Airplay. Seemed logical as a bunch of people are working on standardized cross-platform approaches to Airplay, and the Wifi chip supports these variants. But Chromecast is not using mirroring or Miracast or Wifi Direct. As others have reported, all data to your TV is streamed directly to Chromecast from the cloud.

To really appreciate what this means you need to look at the diagram in this post and showcased on Google’s dev portal. It explicitly shows how Google approached the channelization of wireless video that is coming to your PC, and how they separated the control plane (the second screen device controlling the video) from the data plane (the actual video coming down from the cloud to Chromecast via WiFi).

Out of band control and data is non-trivial and there are a lot of pieces at work here: firmware & driver level (embedded in the SoC—more on this below), OS layer, app layer, etc.

Separating data and control is commonly done in wireless networks, but often both are sent through the same pipe. There are always tradeoffs between user experience, latency, and resources because control data can’t be dropped—you’ll lose things like billing info, channel number, connection status, etc… whereas it’s actually okay for some data to be dropped and lost (e.g. a pixel in a frame of a video—no one will see it or miss it).

After making some calls to friends in the valley I’ve found out more about Chromecast’s internals—the chip inside is the Marvell dual-core ARM7-based DE3005. Very similar to this one, which was in the previous Google TV.  Google pays at most $10 for this chip. Because this SoC includes Wi-Fi, the GPU, and the dual core application processor itself, there aren’t many other expensive components on the board.

Believe it or not, for $35 resale Google will be making money on Chromecast. In fact the total BOM of Chromecast is likely less than $20!

This is because the major difference in the bill of materials between Chromecast and the Apple TV is the 8GB of internal Flash memory on the Apple TV, which is very expensive. Teardowns will reveal how much RAM Chromecast has, but it can likely get away with 512MB, just enough to buffer video, not store it for retrieval—again there is no Flash.

Not chasing the dream of being the hub of the TV (a la set top box and every previous Google attempt) is possibly a very smart move on their part. It’s Google’s most compelling entrée yet to the living room, because it demonstrates firsthand how their service and device ecosystem serve as satellites and controls for the TV.

By separating data and control planes, Google is essentially handing off the control and delivery of the content to application and services up the stack. And they couldn’t do that without control over distribution.

Google’s last few years of decisions across services and apps have given power to ordinary users (you) who want to stream video between screens, and taken power away from the central hub or set top box. However, this only works if Google can distribute its apps and services across devices and platforms.

The biggest example of how this strategy is coming together for Google is the iOS YouTube app, which could very well end up being the most used “client” for Chromecast (iPhones, iPod Touches and iPads number in the tens of millions across US living rooms).

The genius yet subtle win here for Google dates to when they unbundled Youtube from being baked into iOS and made it a separate app. If it was still built in, they would NOT have been able to add a “send to Chromecast” button and iOS devices would not be able to natively play YouTube via Chromecast, which they’ll obviously be able to do when Google releases a new rev of the app.

This fact that Google now controls YouTube on the iPhone (remember it was only about a year ago when YouTube was a “stock”  app and Apple limited distribution apart from yearly iOS revisions) gives them immense power. It also makes the proliferation of the Chrome browser play smart. Extends playback from PCs overnight.

All of this points to Chromecast as the most elegant solution yet for “video redistribution” among screens in the home. The previous GoogleTV stuff was just a big joke. This is the right way to do this. Google can start steamrolling a lot of folks like Roku quickly if they get traction with this device.

Indeed as a wedge in to the living room, there is little doubt to me that we’re looking at the first major winner from Google. A lot of Chromecast’s unique tweaks—to decouple data and control in separate channels and enable the user to queue and buffer videos while not encumbering the 2nd screen device from doing other things could very well be part of the elegance Steve Jobs was referencing when he claimed he cracked the code for video.  But Apple isn’t standing still either, and it’s going to be a very fun and competitive next push into television and video for us all to sit back and watch.

49 responses to “Chromecast and How Google Cracked the Code of Video”

  1. reece says:

    awesome analysis Steve

    we took a look at the tech and think it’s a smart move, but am hopeful that all of those smarts are available to 3rd party developers just the same

    my thoughts on it, here: http://shelbytv.tumblr.com/post/56388664551/3-reasons-why-chromecast-may-succeed

  2. Daniel Benny Simanjuntak says:

    Definitely has more brainpower than he knows what to do with. Was he wearing Glass?

  3. mfilipov says:

    I was wondering why they took the box approach again (correction dongle) while pure software solutions are available. Technologies like iMediaShare have proven that you can solve the discovery issues and provide seamless playback on almost any device without the need to add new hardware.

  4. Fanfoot says:

    The BOM cost? Did you include assembly at somebody like Plexus? They like to make a profit too you know. And manufacturing test–somebody has to burn the boot image onto the device. The box, USB cable, HDMI extension cable, wall wart, all cost money too. Plus somebody to pack it all. I highly doubt they’re making much of a profit on this.

    • steve cheney says:

      Thanks for reading. Yes the BOM I was estimating is total, not just the PCB – the plastic housing and HDMI in bulk are dollars. $20 is a reasonable estimate. iFixit might show $25 when they do a teardown. Assembly at ODMs is cheaper than you could ever imagine, low single digit margin. Google is definitely making a profit, albeit small. But it’s intended as a wedge in, and they’re willing to make low margin. Win for the consumer all the way around.

  5. […] device needs a lot of horsepower (e.g. gaming platforms or STB). Why? The entire BOM of Chromecast is $20 and Intel simply can’t price low enough to compete while preserving margin. Meanwhile, Apple […]

  6. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Informations here: stevecheney.com/chromecast-and-how-google-cracked-the-code-of-video/ […]

  7. … [Trackback]

    […] Find More Informations here: stevecheney.com/chromecast-and-how-google-cracked-the-code-of-video/ […]

  8. Sources

    check under, are a few completely unrelated internet sites to ours, on the other hand, there’re most reputable sources that we use

  9. Study was remarkable, keep in touch

    please explore the webpages we follow, like this one, given it represents our picks through the online

  10. Gems kind the net

    incredibly couple of internet websites that materialize for being in depth beneath, from our perspective are unquestionably well definitely worth trying out

  11. Exceptional web page

    normally a big enthusiast of linking to bloggers that I really like but don’t get a wide range of website link adore from

  12. Dreary Day

    It absolutely was a dreary day below now, so I just took to messing approximately online and identified

  13. Weblogs ou should certainly be browsing

    The following is really a Superb Web site You can Come across Intriguing that we Stimulate You

  14. Learn was unique, stay in touch

    be sure to pay a visit to the web pages we pursue, like this one particular, as it signifies our picks in the online

  15. More Help says:

    Learn was intriguing, keep in touch

    please explore the sites we adopt, among them this an individual, while it represents our picks within the online

  16. Web pages we Like

    Every once in a very even when we decide upon weblogs that we browse. Listed under are the hottest websites that we prefer

  17. Sites we think it’s best to check out

    although internet sites we backlink to beneath are significantly not relevant to ours, we truly feel they really are definitely truly worth a go through, so possess a look

  18. You must examine this out

    Webpages of fascination now we have a website link to

  19. More Tips says:

    Web pages we Like

    Every once in a very even when we decide upon weblogs that we browse. Listed under are the hottest websites that we prefer

  20. Investigate this out

    that may be the conclusion of the content. The following you are going to discover some online sites that we believe you will enjoy, just click on the links more than

  21. Great internet site

    The specifics outlined in the publish are a several for the highly best readily available

  22. Weblogs ou must be studying

    Right here is really a Terrific Blog You could possibly Identify Engaging that we Inspire You

  23. Salvador Cochrum

    we arrived across a amazing online site which you can acquire pleasure in. Take a search after you want

  24. Continuing says:

    Recommeneded websites

    Here are a few of the web sites we suggest for our visitors

  25. Swiftest process to melt away belly unwanted fat fast

    Every as soon as within a once we opt for weblogs that we study. Detailed underneath are classified as the most active web pages that we opt for

  26. Cambridgeshire marriage ceremony photographer

    amongst our visitors a short when ago advocated the following web-site

  27. Full Review says:

    Great web pages

    consistently a giant enthusiast of linking to bloggers that I love but don’t get a lot of backlink adore from

  28. Gems in the world wide web

    particularly couple of sites that take place to become in-depth underneath, from our standpoint are definitely perfectly definitely worth looking at

  29. sources says:

    Read was captivating, remain in touch

    please check out the web sites we stick to, like this a particular, since it represents our picks from your web

  30. Dreary Day

    It was a dreary day listed here right now, so I just took to messing roughly online and located

  31. Online sites we Like

    Any the moment within a while we choose weblogs that we read through. Outlined beneath are classified as the most recently released webpages that we decide upon

  32. Web-sites you’ll want to pay a visit to

    down below you’ll find the url to some online websites that we believe it is advisable to check out

  33. Over the internet Post

    The data pointed out inside content are some of the greatest on the market

  34. Cambridgeshire wedding photographer

    considered one of our visitors a short even while ago preferred the following site

  35. Gems with the net

    incredibly few webpages that come about to generally be comprehensive under, from our standpoint are definitely properly price looking at

  36. Fantastic websites

    we arrived throughout a wonderful online site that you just may well relish. Just take a look if you want

  37. Wonderful web site

    the time to look at or pay a visit to the material or webpages we’ve got related to beneath the

  38. Online sites we Like

    Nearly every once in a very even when we prefer weblogs that we read through. Listed down below will be the hottest online sites that we determine

  39. Examine was captivating, continue to be in contact

    you should head over to the online sites we carry out, like this a person, given it signifies our picks in the web

  40. World-wide Site visitors Machine critique

    please pay a visit to the world wide web webpages we follow, similar to this a single individual, because it represents our picks from your website

  41. Hyperlinks

    Online websites of interest now we have a link to

  42. Remarkable blog

    The details outlined within the article are a couple of of your especially most desirable readily available

  43. World-wide Site visitors Machine critique

    please pay a visit to the world wide web webpages we follow, similar to this a single individual, because it represents our picks from your website

  44. Gems from your world wide web

    especially couple web-sites that transpire for being specific beneath, from our viewpoint are without doubt very well truly worth checking out

  45. more says:

    Gems from your web-based

    exceptionally several webpages that transpire to become specific beneath, from our viewpoint are certainly well worth checking out

  46. Salvador Cochrum

    we came throughout a great site which chances are you’ll acquire satisfaction in. Require a research at the time you want

  47. Customer recommendations

    certainly one of our guests not too long ago proposed the next online site

  48. inteist says:

    Good article, appreciate the analysis, thanks!

Tweet or Like this post.